A Foodie Guide to the Best Places to Eat in Amelia Island

Located along the coast of northeastern Florida, Amelia Island offers not only stunning views but also a vibrant culinary scene that will tantalize your taste buds. From fresh seafood to savory barbecue and everything in between, there’s no shortage of delectable dining options to explore on this charming island. Join me on a culinary adventure as we uncover the best places to eat in Amelia Island, where every meal is a delightful experience.

The Best Places to Eat in Amelia Island

Whether you’re craving fresh seafood, indulgent desserts, or craft cocktails, you’ll find something to satisfy your cravings on this charming island. From casual beachside eateries to upscale dining establishments, the best places to eat in Amelia Island offer something for every taste and budget.

Timoti’s Seafood Shak

For a taste of the freshest seafood on Amelia Island, head to Timoti’s Seafood Shak in downtown Fernandina Beach. This laid-back eatery specializes in casual coastal cuisine, offering a menu of seafood favorites like fish tacos, shrimp baskets, and poke bowls. With its relaxed atmosphere and outdoor seating, Timoti’s is the perfect spot to enjoy a leisurely lunch or dinner with friends and family.

Wicked Bao

For a taste of Asian-inspired cuisine with a modern twist, look no further than Wicked Bao. This cozy eatery offers a creative menu of steamed buns, rice bowls, and small plates bursting with flavor. Don’t miss their signature bao buns filled with savory meats, crispy veggies, and zesty sauces. With its laid-back atmosphere and innovative dishes, Wicked Bao is a must-visit for foodies craving bold flavors.

Mason’s Famous Lobster Rolls

Indulge in the ultimate seaside treat with a visit to Mason’s Famous Lobster Rolls, where every bite is a taste of coastal comfort. Specializing in fresh Maine lobster served in buttery toasted rolls, Mason’s offers a mouthwatering menu of lobster-centric dishes that are sure to satisfy seafood lovers. Whether you prefer your lobster roll traditional or with a twist, Mason’s Famous Lobster Rolls promises a dining experience that’s as delicious as it is unforgettable.

Tasty’s Burgers

Sometimes, nothing hits the spot quite like a juicy burger and a side of crispy fries. At Tasty’s Burgers, you’ll find exactly that and more. This beloved burger joint serves up a mouthwatering selection of gourmet burgers, fries, and delicious milkshakes. Tasty’s Burgers has something for everyone!

Salty Pelican

Experience the laid-back charm of coastal living at the Salty Pelican, a waterfront restaurant offering breathtaking views of the Amelia River. Specializing in fresh seafood and classic American fare, the Salty Pelican prides itself on serving up delicious dishes made with locally sourced ingredients. Whether you’re enjoying a leisurely meal on the outdoor patio or sipping cocktails at the rooftop bar, a visit to the Salty Pelican is sure to be a memorable dining experience.

Sandbar Amelia Island

For laid-back beach vibes and delicious food, head to Sandbar Amelia Island located right on the beach. This waterfront restaurant offers stunning views of the Atlantic Ocean and a menu of casual coastal cuisine, including fresh seafood, burgers, and tacos. Pull up a chair on the outdoor patio or relax in the beachfront bar. With its relaxed atmosphere and beachfront location, Sandbar is the perfect spot to unwind and enjoy the beauty of Amelia Island.

Mezcal

Transport your taste buds to Mexico with a visit to Mezcal, a vibrant restaurant serving up authentic Mexican cuisine in the heart of downtown Fernandina Beach. From flavorful tacos to refreshing margaritas and handcrafted cocktails, Mezcal offers a culinary journey through the rich and diverse flavors of Mexico. With its colorful decor, lively atmosphere, and delicious food, Mezcal is the perfect spot for a fiesta with friends and family.

David’s Restaurant and Lounge

For a fine dining experience that’s sure to impress, make a reservation at David’s in downtown Fernandina Beach. This elegant restaurant offers a menu of upscale American cuisine with a focus on fresh, locally sourced ingredients. From perfectly seared steaks to delicate seafood dishes, each plate at David’s is a work of art. Pair your meal with a glass of wine from their extensive list of international and domestic selections for the ultimate dining experience.

Island Time Ice Cream

When the sun is shining and you need a cool treat to beat the heat, head to Island Time Ice Cream in downtown Fernandina Beach. This ice cream parlor offers a mouthwatering selection of ice cream flavors, including classics like vanilla and chocolate, as well as unique creations like salted caramel pretzel and banana pudding. Whether you prefer a cone, cup, or sundae, Island Time Ice Cream has the perfect scoop for every craving.

Vintage Donuts

For those with a penchant for pastries, Vintage Donuts is a must-visit destination on Amelia Island. Located in downtown Fernandina Beach, this charming donut shop serves up a delicious array of freshly baked donuts in a variety of flavors and styles. Customize your donuts by selecting your donut, frosting, and toppings!

The Tavern by Amelia Island Brewing Company

For beer enthusiasts looking to quench their thirst, look no further than The Tavern by Amelia Island Brewing Company. This popular brewery offers a rotating selection of craft beers brewed on-site. Pull up a seat at the bar or relax on the outdoor patio as you sample flights of beer and food offerings. The giant pretzel is a must! With its laid-back atmosphere and creative brews, Amelia Island Brewing Company is a favorite hangout spot.

Amelia Island Coffee

For coffee lovers in need of a caffeine fix, Amelia Island Coffee is the place to be. Located in downtown Fernandina Beach, this cozy coffee shop serves up a variety of specialty coffee drinks made with freshly roasted beans. Whether you prefer a classic espresso or a creamy latte, Amelia Island Coffee has you covered. Pair your coffee with a freshly baked pastry or breakfast sandwich for the perfect start to your day.

Looking for more tips for visiting Amelia Island? Check out my 3 Day Amelia Island Itinerary for Couples.

With its diverse culinary landscape and abundance of delicious dining options, Amelia Island is a paradise for food lovers. From seaside restaurants with stunning views to cozy cafes and bustling breweries, there’s something to satisfy every craving on this charming island. So pack your appetite and prepare to embark on a culinary adventure filled with unforgettable flavors and delightful discoveries—all on the beautiful shores of Amelia Island.