Please note, this post may contain affiliate links. Visit Devine Fairytale’s Disclosure Policy for more details.
Amelia Island is the kind of coastal getaway that makes you want to slow down in the best way. The beaches are gorgeous, downtown Fernandina Beach is full of charm, and the Amelia Island dining scene is a big reason people fall in love with this place. If you’re trying to narrow down the best places to eat in Amelia Island, you’ll find everything from fresh seafood and lobster rolls to donuts and coffee shops.
This guide shares Amelia Island restaurants that are worth building your itinerary around.
What to Know About Amelia Island Dining Before You Go
Amelia Island dining is laid-back overall, but a few things will make your experience even better, especially if you’re visiting during a busy season.
Downtown Fernandina Beach is where you’ll find a big concentration of restaurants, coffee shops, and dessert stops all within an easy walk. It’s perfect to park and wander throughout the evening. You can grab dinner, pop into a shop, and finish with a sweet treat without needing to drive all over the island.
If you’re visiting on a weekend, around holidays, or during peak travel times, dinner can get busy fast. For more popular Amelia Island restaurants, making a reservation is the move if it’s offered. If reservations are not an option, going a little earlier than your usual dinner time can save you from a long wait.
Plan for at least one meal where the main attraction is the view. There are a few spots where you can sit by the water, order something simple, and just soak it in.
The Best Places to Eat in Amelia Island
Whether you’re craving fresh seafood, indulgent desserts, or craft cocktails, you’ll find something to satisfy your cravings. From casual beachside eateries to upscale dining establishments, the best places to eat in Amelia Island offer something for every taste and budget.
Timoti’s Seafood Shak
For a taste of the freshest seafood on Amelia Island, head to Timoti’s Seafood Shak in downtown Fernandina Beach. This spot is known for coastal favorites like fish tacos, shrimp baskets, and poke bowls. The outdoor seating is a big part of the vibe, especially on a sunny day. It’s a great lunch option and also works well for a low-key dinner when you still want something really good.
Wicked Bao
For a taste of Asian-inspired cuisine with a modern twist, look no further than Wicked Bao. Their menu is packed with bold, Asian-inspired flavors like steamed bao buns, rice bowls, and shareable small plates that are perfect if you like trying a little bit of everything. It’s casual, creative, and a great change of pace if you’ve been doing seafood all day. If you’re a foodie who loves flavorful sauces and dishes that feel a little different, add this to your Amelia Island dining plans.
Mason’s Famous Lobster Rolls
If lobster rolls are on your vacation wishlist, Mason’s Famous Lobster Rolls is the spot. They serve Maine lobster on buttery toasted rolls, and it truly feels like a coastal treat. Whether you prefer your lobster roll traditional or with a twist, Mason’s Famous Lobster Rolls promises a dining experience that’s as delicious as it is unforgettable. If you want one meal that feels like a signature Amelia Island moment, this is a strong contender.
Tasty’s Burgers
Tasty’s Burgers is comfort food done right. When you want a juicy burger, crispy fries, and a milkshake that tastes like the reward for walking around all day, this is the spot. The menu is approachable and family-friendly, but it still feels like a local favorite that people genuinely love. It’s also a great option when not everyone in your group wants seafood.
Salty Pelican
The Salty Pelican is a must if you love waterfront dining. Overlooking the Amelia River, this spot is known for seafood and classic American fare, plus views that make you want to linger. Whether you’re enjoying a meal on the outdoor patio or sipping cocktails at the rooftop bar, a visit to the Salty Pelican is sure to be a memorable dining experience.
Sandbar Amelia Island
Sandbar Amelia Island is perfect for beach vibes and a casual menu. Located right on the beach, it’s the kind of spot where you can go from sandy toes to a table with an ocean view without overthinking it. The menu includes seafood, burgers, tacos, and other coastal favorites that work for lunch or dinner. If you want a relaxed meal with views of the Atlantic, Sandbar is one of the best places to eat in Amelia Island.
Mezcal
Mezcal is a fun pick for a lively dinner in downtown Fernandina Beach. The menu features authentic Mexican dishes with lots of flavor, plus margaritas and cocktails that make it feel like a night out. With its colorful decor, lively atmosphere, and delicious food, Mezcal is the perfect spot for a fiesta with friends and family.
David’s Restaurant and Lounge
For a more upscale night, David’s Restaurant and Lounge is the best choice. The menu is upscale American cuisine with fresh, locally sourced ingredients, and every dish feels thoughtfully done. From perfectly seared steaks to delicate seafood dishes, each plate at David’s is a work of art. Pair your meal with a glass of wine from their extensive list for the ultimate dining experience.
Island Time Ice Cream
When the sun is shining and you need a cool treat to beat the heat, head to Island Time Ice Cream in downtown Fernandina Beach. This ice cream parlor offers a mouthwatering selection of ice cream flavors, including classics like vanilla and chocolate, as well as unique creations like salted caramel pretzel and banana pudding. Whether you prefer a cone or cup, Island Time Ice Cream has the perfect scoop for every craving.
Vintage Donuts
Vintage Donuts is a fun morning stop, especially because you can customize your donut by choosing the base, frosting, and toppings. Everything is fresh and it’s a great grab-and-go option before a day at the beach or exploring downtown. If you like starting vacation mornings with a sweet treat and good coffee, add this to your list.
The Tavern by Amelia Island Brewing Company
If craft beer is part of your vacation vibe, The Tavern by Amelia Island Brewing Company is worth a stop. This popular brewery offers a rotating selection of craft beers brewed on-site. Pull up a seat at the bar or relax on the outdoor patio as you sample flights of beer and food offerings. The giant pretzel is a must! With its laid-back atmosphere and creative brews, Amelia Island Brewing Company is a favorite hangout spot.
Amelia Island Coffee
For coffee lovers in need of a caffeine fix, Amelia Island Coffee is the place to be. In downtown Fernandina Beach, this cozy coffee shop serves up a variety of specialty coffee drinks. Whether you prefer a classic espresso or a creamy latte, Amelia Island Coffee has you covered. Pair your coffee with a freshly baked pastry or breakfast sandwich for the perfect start to your day.
Looking for more tips for visiting Amelia Island? Check out my 3 Day Amelia Island Itinerary for Couples.
The History Behind the Best Places to Eat in Amelia Island
The best places to eat in Amelia Island are shaped by the island’s coastal history. Fernandina Beach’s roots as a port town created a strong connection to seafood, which remains a foundation of Amelia Island dining today.
Many Amelia Island restaurants are independently owned and located in historic buildings, reflecting the island’s long-standing focus on preservation and community. This history gives dining here a more personal feel compared to larger beach destinations.
That blend of coastal heritage and local ownership is part of what makes the best places to eat in Amelia Island feel genuine. Meals here are not just about the food, but about experiencing the island’s character through its dining scene.
Amelia Island Dining FAQs
- What are the best places to eat in Amelia Island?
- Some of the most popular Amelia Island restaurants include Timoti’s Seafood Shak, Mason’s Famous Lobster Rolls, Wicked Bao, and David’s.
- Are Amelia Island restaurants walkable?
- Many Amelia Island restaurants are walkable if you are staying near downtown Fernandina Beach.
- Is Amelia Island dining family friendly?
- Yes. Many Amelia Island restaurants offer casual menus and welcoming atmospheres that work well for families.
- Do you need reservations for Amelia Island dining?
- Reservations are recommended for dinner at popular or upscale spots, especially on weekends and during busy seasons.
- What is Amelia Island known for food-wise?
- Amelia Island is best known for fresh seafood, lobster rolls, casual coastal cuisine, and relaxed waterfront dining.
Why Amelia Island Is a Destination for Food Lovers
Amelia Island is the kind of place where food becomes part of the story of your trip. With a wide variety of Amelia Island restaurants, it’s easy to plan days that feel relaxed, indulgent, and memorable without ever feeling rushed.
From fresh seafood to cozy coffee shops, casual beachside meals, and elevated dinners, the best places to eat in Amelia Island offer something for every mood and every moment. This guide will help plan your dining options so your meals are part of the magic of your time on the island.
